
Marketplace vs traditional eCommerce
The terms ‘marketplace’ and ‘drop-shipping‘ have become quite popular in recent years, especially with the rise of ebay, Amazon and the likes.
You can find lots of information about how drop-shipping is the easy way to make lots of money online. However, there’s lots more to it that just listing someone’s product on your website.
Just like any business, running a marketplace using a drop-ship-model comes with its own set of challenges.
We spoke to Tiffany Benn, founder of Hart Home Decor, about how she built her drop-ship marketplace for Aussie-designed and -made homewares, and grew it into an award-winning platform.
Why did you build a marketplace instead of a traditional eCommerce store?
The main reason I decided on a marketplace rather than having a traditional eCommerce store was because I didn’t want to hold any stock.
Also, I’m a terrible buyer. I know about interiors, but I didn’t want the risk of buying the wrong products and being stuck with the stock.
Running a marketplace was a risk-free way to own the kind of store I wanted.
What were the challenges of building your marketplace?
The main challenge for me was trying to get across to the developers, exactly what I wanted. I knew what the end goal was, but I didn’t know how to get there. The first website was badly built and had to be rebuilt it at a later stage.
In saying that, on the flip side, if I were to build this website now from scratch, it would probably cost me $100,000. But because I built it in stages and started small, and a lot of the backend was heavily manual, it helped me work out along the way what I needed for the next website.
In the beginning, I was adding all the products myself. So for the next version of the website, my developer told me about having a vendor plugin. This meant people selling on the website could then log into their own section of the website, add their products and manage their own store effectively. And because I was doing everything manually in the beginning, that helped me understand how to take the site to the next level.
How do you manage the interactions between buyers and sellers?
The beginning part wasn’t very easy to manage, because I was literally the middle person. I’d get an order, and then forward it to the seller myself. It was super manual! But that’s just what it took to get the marketplace up and running.
There were a couple of years where I was doing 18-hour-days, everyday! During this time, it took about 6 months for me to find a developer, get the website redesigned and rebuilt. Had I had more money at the beginning, I would’ve been able to pay for some advice and for a better developer. But it was all done on bootstrap.
The process is much more automated now. The orders go directly to the seller, because they’ve all got their own store on the website. I just keep an eye on things and focus on the marketing of the platform.
What do you think makes a marketplace successful?
Automation
I think it’s important for a marketplace to have a really high level of automation that works properly. Having as much automation as possible means there’s no real need for me to get involved in the buying and selling part. It then frees up more time for me to work on marketing, instead of manually handling the operations.
Having looked at very successful competitors, the majority of their time and budget is spent on marketing. It’s not on admin in the backend. That needs to be done by somebody else, so you can focus on the money-making.
Marketing
You have to keep changing and improving as you go. It’s not easy but it is what it is.
When I was first starting out, I was trying everything, like doing market stalls. It became apparent pretty fast that the way forward was digital marketing. Everybody’s looking at their phones all day, so that’s where they’d find you.
Right now, my main forms of marketing are social media platforms Instagram and Facebook. For my eDMs I use Mailchimp, and I write blog posts on the website. All the content produced is used across all the platforms.
I also do a little bit of wholesale on the side, so part of my time is taken up with that. But mostly it’s writing content and building my email list through free giveaways or printables.
How do you find products that can be drop-shipped?
In my brain, there’s two types of drop-shipping. There’s the nice one, and the not-so-nice one.
Often, when you use the term ‘drop-shipping’, people associate it with dodginess or other negative connotations. If you search on Google, ‘how do I start a drop-shipping website’, a lot of the articles will say “find a good product and sell it to a billion people”. I’m sure people do make a lot of money out of it, but it’s got a bit of a bad reputation. That’s the not-so-nice one.
The other form of drop-shipping, which a lot of businesses do choose, (let’s call this the nice one) is a lot more manual and takes time to build up. This is the type of drop-shipping I do. I basically spent the first year and half on Instagram finding designers that would drop-ship their products.
The sellers on my website are Australian businesses who produce handmade products. A lot of it is made to order: Personalised Christmas ornaments, prints, things like that. It takes a week or two to get out to the customer, but it’s a much more transparent form of drop-shipping.
To have a really nice worthwhile business, find products that you actually like and care about – products that you actually want to sell and buy.
What are your top 3 tips for people wanting to start a marketplace?
Start small
I wouldn’t go out and spend $100,000+ on a custom-built website and instead start small. Lots of people love Shopify for their traditional eCommerce stores. It’s not the best for drop-shipping in Australia (all the apps are US-based and the delivery lead times are huge), but WordPress is certainly very good for it. It’s easy to use, but make sure you have a developer who does the coding and keeps the site up-to-date.
Just launch
I waited 6 months until I had 300 products on the website before I launched it. I was stupid! Sitting there waiting for 300 products on your website is a true waste of time. I should’ve had it out there, because nobody can find you until you start marketing anyway. It’s not like you’re going to launch your website and the whole world is going to start shopping with you.
If you have one product, great. I’d launch, even with no products, it’s not a big deal. There’s a lot of things you can do to build up excitement, with messages like ‘coming soon’, or ‘can’t wait to show you what we’re going to launch!’
Don’t worry, nobody will be looking at it anyway for the first few months! I’d start a blog first to build up SEO, and then add the products as I go along.
Focus on SEO
Speaking of SEO, the third tip is to learn SEO from the start, before you do anything else. Or get someone to do it for you, someone who knows what they’re doing (steer away from long-term contracts or people who’s prices are too good to be true).
If you don’t have that, you’re essentially wasting your time. Because nobody is going to find you.
It’s great having a social media following, but at the end of the day, a lot of people are searching on Google. So if you’re not coming up somewhere on Google, eventually, it’s going to be very, very hard. Make sure you get that sorted from the start, before you even think about setting your website live.
If you’d like reliable local support for your website, or have a new project coming up, get in touch with us at hello@consideredagency.com.au.

